Red's Pizza, Fostoria (2024)

Hours

Open Today:

11:00am-2:00am
Monday11:00am-12:00am
Tuesday11:00am-12:00am
Wednesday11:00am-12:00am
Thursday11:00am-12:00am
Friday11:00am-2:00am
Saturday11:00am-2:00am
Sunday11:00am-12:00am

View the Menu

View Menus

Restaurant Description

XLarge Pizza Sauge Pernie Banna peppers double Cheese & double cheese & a large Italian SUb and large Chicken Wings!!!!

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

See Menus

Write a Review for Red's Pizza

Top Reviews of Red's Pizza

04/16/2024 - MenuPix User

04/09/2024 - MenuPix User

02/29/2024 - MenuPix User

12/05/2023 - MenuPix User

03/01/2023 - Chad
They have a buffet on wednesdays, at least that's what the sandwich board outside says, from 11-2 but dont expect pizza to be on the buffet, I know I'm a little out of line expecting pizza at a pizza place. Went in at noon, aside from no pizza the customer service? I'd rather clean their toilets with my younger than talk to the dirtbag tattoo lady...she slams stuff around, cusses, sighs over and o er, it wasn't even friggin busy and this woman was absolutely overwhelmed...I will never go back. Be wary of who you hire, your food may be spectacular (I'll never know about the pizza) but your customer service is like you only hire from prison reformatories. Best of luck but your employees will sink you

08/04/2021 - CHERYL
i wil be 72 this month order subs from here our the best ones we have ever had n thats the whole truth buy one or more love the blt husband ham n cheese order was deliver fastt PERFECT

05/23/2021 - Patti
Hands down the best pizza! The pizza is out of this world, they don't skimp on the toppings. Worth the drive.

02/06/2021 - Sharon F.
We have gotten Red's Pizza exclusively for many of years. My oldest lives in Toledo now and I'm the other 2 are in MI. They always want Red's when they come home😋😋😋😋

08/10/2020 - Tammy
We have ordered here 4 years and after the owner passed away the service went down hill but I had to tell ya the last 2 time we have ordered here our food was amazing last night our fold over was on point cheese and all hot and a good delivery time last week we ordered dinner and the cheese bread and all was great I don't know what has changed in the past few years but keep it up a happy customer

03/11/2020 - MenuPix User
Staff was very courteous pizza was perfect and ready when promised would definitely recommend and will order again

08/04/2018 - Sue Sharp
Love love love your food

06/02/2018 - Rick
ordered pizza last night and the cheese doesn't even taste real. This place is going down faster and faster

06/01/2018 - Shielowe
food has for sure gone down hill. salads are brown pizza is either burnt or gooey. last time we ordered the bread we couldn't eat t Tasted like chemicals. wont order again Have said it before and after a few months or so tried and the same thing and now the past year it is really bad.. Hate to say it but the business across the street from them is tasting better and I never ever thought I would say that

05/05/2017 - K. Litton
This is the third time that I've ordered since Jim (the owner) passed. The food is not the same. The service is horrible. You're told 35-40 mins for your order. Over an hour later still no food. You call and they say it's just leaving. If you're busy or know that you'll be busy, let the customers know. Jim would tell us he was busy it would be about an hour. My food would be ready at that time. When tell people a time that their food will be ready at certain time, that's when then they expect it. They need to learn how to run a business.

03/23/2017 - Derrick
Have gotten horrible service and pies from them the last three times I have ordered will never order there again

02/20/2015 - frank
Too busy got cold pizza brought wrong slip to sign for my debit card

01/25/2015 - John Dough
I have known Jim (the owner) forever, and he is a great guy.
He also knows how to make a GREAT pie, but he seems to have stopped doing it very consistently. The last several months, the ingredients have gotten skimpy, (especially the cheese) and the evening crews have become a complete train wreck.....(Forgot to put the order in....forgot ingredients....charged the wrong price...told me 25 minutes, and then took 55...etc. etc.) By the way.....I don't care if it's 55 minutes to get a pie.....I understand things get busy sometimes.... but just tell me the truth when I order.
There are new faces behind the counter in the evenings almost every time you go in, and that CAN"T be helping much.
I suggested a while back to them that I understand that cheese is the most expensive topping, but that they needed to pick up the old habits of adding cheese...even if they need to adjust prices. Well....it hasn't happened, so I quit doing business there, and am paying the extra $1 to $1.50 at their main competitor, and getting a good pie again.
The only thing left there is the lunch buffet (which is $6.25 including your drink....a real bargain in my opinion) and the daytime people do a fairly good job.
As for my evening pickup or delivery orders, I will no longer be calling on Reds. It's too bad, because they KNOW how to do it right, but they have stopped.

11/21/2014 - Ceejae
They have the best of the best when it comes to there bread.. Yummyyyyyyyyyy

04/13/2014 - Mark
I quit ordering from Reds. Seems the pizza is either burnt or gooey.... Salads are brown. Use to be my favorite but now unless its free im not going back. The owner Terri has a nasty rep. two faced and thinks she is better then others and she is just a drunk.

Menu

Show All Menus